Windows 8 Consumer Preview – Metro and Desktop compared

The word “metro” brings to mind terms like urbane, sophisticated, stylish, refined, while “desktop” says plain, modest, functional. Windows users, of course, know that this is not the way to describe the Windows Desktop. In the Windows 8 Consumer Preview those terms for “Metro” are, let’s say, premature. Metro is a new way of interacting with your computer. There is much to like and there are some tantalizing hints of things to come. imageThe Windows 8 CP desktop and desktop programs are not just copies from Windows 7 but bring new features and functionality.

There are several desktop programs or features that have counterparts in the new Metro world.

Internet Explorer 10 comes as a desktop program as well as a Metro app. This gives me a chance to make some comparisons. I should say at the outset, that such appraisal is unfair since the Metro interface and apps are just previews, and very much a subset of what is to come. The Metro interface and the apps are new and still in development while on the desktop side we see refinements on many years evolution.

imageRunning Internet Explorer 10 on the desktop and running the IE Metro app at the same time shows that these are worlds apart and don’t share with each other. imageThe favorites lists are not shared. Logging in to a site on one will not log you in to the same site on the other. The Metro IE is definitely aimed at the smaller devices.

There is an interesting difference between Metro IE and desktop IE: I logged into my favorite music service, Pandora on both. Yes, separate log-ins required. Playing music on the desktop will continue to play when other apps, including Metro apps are selected in the foreground. When playing the music in the Metro version the sound stops when switching to another app, but continues when going to another site in IE.

Some other differences between Metro and desktop are also notable.

imageimagePinning a site or program to the taskbar provides a jump list when the icon is right-clicked. That feature is not present with items pinned to the Start screen. All you get there is an option to “Unpin from Start”.

The Windows 8 Consumer Preview comes with a Metro Mail app. This too, is an “APP PREVIEW”. imageOn the Start screen the Mail tile pages through current items in the inbox so you can instantly tell that there is new mail. Clicking the tile brings up a full screen – all Metro apps run full screen. The layout is clean and pleasant. Three columns show the connected accounts on the left, the listings of the emails in the center, with a reading pane on the right to display the content of a selected email.


Icons in the upper right image allow creating a new email, responding to the selected email, or discarding it. A taskbar like area at the bottom, in response to a right-click, provides additional options.

The “new email” page is very Spartan looking, but functional.


There is a limited but adequate range of fonts, text sizes, colors, etc. I have not found how to paste an image, except for emoticons, but there is an “Attachments” link. The attach options provides a very clean page for selecting a photo or document from the computer. No sign yet of photo emails.

For a detailed “get-started” with Windows 8 CP Mail, see Technogran’s tittle tattle post, on “Setting up Mail”.

The desktop side of Windows 8 Consumer Preview does not have a mail client installed. I downloaded Windows Live Mail from the Windows Live Essentials page. It installed and worked just like it does in Windows 7. This program is reported in the process of being extensively revised.


© 2011 Ludwig Keck

About Ludwig

Lending a helping hand where I can. . . My motto: If it is worth doing, it is worth doing well.
This entry was posted in Mail, Windows 8 and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Windows 8 Consumer Preview – Metro and Desktop compared

  1. technogran says:

    Very nice summary of how you are finding the new METRO apps Ludwig. There is a lot more to come and I for one can’t wait, especially for Live Writer et al to be converted into a METRO app! Will be very interesting to say the least. Have you tried out search in Mail app? It also works in any of the METRO apps and is a very welcome addition. In the Mail app it will search all of your emails in any given email account for a term, phrase etc, and is very similar to ‘Active Search’ that Brian Starbuck and his team were working on years ago.

Comments are closed.